Eagles NFL
101316DougPederson Paul Sancya/AP

Eagles offensive coaches review my grades, unanimously agree that they're all undeniably correct.

October 13, 2016

Eagles report cards after four games: Offense edition

The Philadelphia Eagles are a quarter of the way through their first season under Doug Pederson, and are off to a surprising 3-1 start. Now feels like a good time to grade the Eagles' first quarter performances, individually.

QB Carson Wentz: A+

Is there really any question here? Wentz has it all -- great size, a strong arm, athletic ability, accuracy, poise, smarts, improvisational skills, leadership qualities, and competitiveness. 

In fact, according to Reuben Frank of CSN Philly, Wentz has the highest quarterback rating in NFL history for rookie quarterbacks in their first four games:

The Eagles have found their franchise quarterback.


MORE ON THE EAGLES: Redskins could be without best offensive weapon Sunday vs. Eagles | Carson Wentz leaves a big tip for a fan at his alma mater | DeSean Jackson open to return to the Eagles in free agency | Week 6 NFL picks | Eagles power ranking roundup: Birds tumble | Film breakdown: Did Wentz make the right throw on game-ending interception vs. Lions?


RB Ryan Mathews: D

Mathews had a few nice runs against the Bears on Monday Night Football, particularly on the play where he ran into the line, bounced off, kept his balance, and ran in for a score. Otherwise, he's been the least productive of the Eagles' backs, and his fumble against the Lions was an absolutely devastating, inexcusable mistake.

RB Darren Sproles: B

Sproles had a big game against the Steelers, hauling in six passes for 128 yards and a TD, and he was effective running the ball against the Lions in limited chances. Otherwise, he's been relatively quiet in the regular offense, although he also had a 40-yard punt return against the Browns.

RB Wendell Smallwood: B+

In limited action so far this season, Smallwood has 20 rushes for 96 yards and a TD. Against the Steelers, Smallwood showed very good burst, running for 79 yards on 17 carries, even when the Steelers mostly knew the Eagles were running it. He needs more opportunities.

RB Kenjon Barner: B+

During training camp, especially early in camp, I personally didn't think Barner could play and thought his past was too inconsistent. To my surprise, Barner has looked good, running for 86 yards and a TD on 14 carries this season.

WR Jordan Matthews: B-

Drops still persist, but Matthews is still very clearly the Eagles' best weapon in the passing game. On the season, Matthews has 19 catches for 269 yards and 2 TDs. That puts him on pace for 76-1076-8, or right around where he was a year ago.

WR Nelson Agholor: C-

Agholor is certainly a lot better than he was a year ago, which isn't exactly a high bar. So far this season, Agholor has 13 catches for 147 yards and 1 TD. While Wentz was certainly more to blame for the fourth quarter interception against the Lions, Agholor didn't exactly do much to ensure that that pass wasn't picked off. Agholor is on pace for 588 yards, which just isn't good enough for a second-year, first-round wide receiver who is getting a lot of snaps.

WR Dorial Green-Beckham: C

There have been glimpses of what Green-Beckham can do, and clearly, the trade to bring him in for the low low price of one Dennis Kelly was robbery. Still, Green-Beckham's first quarter of the season performance was very inconsistent. He dropped a deep ball against the Steelers that should have been a touchdown:

And while he was possibly interfered with on this fade route in the end zone against Detroit, this is a 5'9, 190-pound corner covering him:

Green-Beckham has nine inches and like 50 pounds on this guy. How about just out-muscling him and making the play?

WR Josh Huff: D

Huff has 8 catches for 24 yards and 3 rushes for 10 yards. That's 11 touches for 34 yards (3.1 yards per touch), and he has not looked good on kick returns, muffing one last Sunday in Detroit. 

TE Zach Ertz: C+

In two games, Ertz has 9 catches for 95 yards, which is fine. However, on two consecutive plays against the Lions, Ertz caught a pass and went down on his own, Jeremy Maclin-style. Whenever Brent Celek gets his hands on the football, he looks to punish opposing defensive backs. You just don't see that often enough from Ertz.

TE Brent Celek: B-

Celek has four catches this season, putting him on pace for 16 on the season, which would be the lowest of his career, although that is no longer his role in the Eagles' offense. Celek remains the best blocking tight end on the team, by far, and his value will increase with Lane Johnson now serving his 10-game suspension.

TE Trey Burton: B+

Burton still isn't playing as much as he should, but when he has gotten opportunities, he has been good. Against the Bears, Burton had five catches for 49 yards and a TD.

Jason Peters: B+

Peters is no longer the star he once was, but he has given Carson Wentz good protection on the blind side, as Wentz has mostly had clean pockets to throw from all season. In the run game, Peters can still do things like this:

Allen Barbre: A

Before the season began, I wondered why the Eagles seemingly just handed the LG spot to Allen Barbre. Welp, that article looks dumb now. Barbre has been one of the major pleasant surprises of the first four games, playing high-quality football to the point where the Eagles don't want to move him and risk messing up what they have on the left side of their offensive line.

Jason Kelce: C+

I already know a lot of you will vehemently disagree with this grade, and I get it. Kelce struggled quite a bit in the first two games against the Browns and Bears when he had to face much bigger NTs like Danny Shelton and Eddie Goldman. However, Kelce does an outstanding job of making line calls and adjustments, which has helped Wentz have the start that he has had.

Brandon Brooks: B-

Brooks has been fine. He hasn't gotten the consistent push you might hope for in the run game. However, there haven't been any egregious errors on his part either. Overall, he has been a huge upgrade at RG.

Lane Johnson: A- (with an F for the next two quarters)

Lane Johnson is playing the best football of his career. Unfortunately, he was suspended for 10 games for his second offense for violating the NFL's policy on performance-enhancing drugs.

The final first quarter report card:

Player 1Q 2Q 3Q 4Q 
 Carson WentzA+    
 Ryan Mathews   
 Darren Sproles   
 Wendell SmallwoodB+    
 Kenjon BarnerB   
 Jordan MatthewsB-    
 Nelson AgholorC-    
 Dorial Green-Beckham   
 Josh Huff   
 Zach ErtzC+    
 Brent CelekB-    
 Trey BurtonB+    
 Jason PetersB+    
 Allen Barbre   
 Jason KelceC+   
 Brandon BrooksB-    
 Lane JohnsonA-  

Follow Jimmy on Twitter: @JimmyKempski

Like Jimmy on Facebook.