Is there really a 'Republican machine' in Philly?

Independent candidate cites long odds to win one of two Council seats

Andrew Stober is the former chief of staff of the Mayor’s Office of Transportation and Utilities in Philadelphia. He ran as an independent for an at-large City Council seat.
Andrew Stober/LinkedIn

I covered the mayoral election on Tuesday. You know, the one that was essentially decided in May?

Surfing through the Election Day coverage Wednesday morning, I stumbled across an epic quote in a story about the Philly City Council races.

Late-to-the-mix independent candidate Andrew Stober – he of the endorsements from former Mayor/Gov. Ed Rendell and current Mayor Michael Nutter – told the Inquirer’s Tricia Nadolny, “I think it's a real reminder, there is a very real Republican machine in this city.”

The 7 a.m. insta-reaction: LOL.

Republican machine? In Philly?

Well, that’s rich.

Granted, the quote came in the heat-of-defeat moment from a candidate – the former chief of staff of the Mayor's Office of Transportation and Utilities is surely a decent man, from all I’ve seen/read/heard – who finished sixth in a nine-person race for a pair of minority-party seats.

With fewer than 17,000 votes, he’d have needed to double that figure to edge out candidates from the traditionally dominant Republican Party of Philadelphia.

Granted, a quick scan of a list of at-large Council members since 1952 didn’t turn up anyone outside the two-party structure – if I missed one, do tell me posthaste (update!) – but there are some other factors at play here, methinks.

Like how even big-name endorsements don’t much matter to Dems who a.) turn out at the polls in lower numbers, b.) pay limited attention to general-election races decided in the party’s primary and c.) aren’t likely to have much impact in a contest that serves as the opposition party’s pretty-much sole mechanism to magnify their voices at City Hall.

Translation: If you were depending on Dems to get fired up in a race that they’ve traditionally never been fired up for, you entered the Colosseum without a sword or shield against lions fighting the only fight they're allowed to win.

But hey, I’m no big-city political candidate. If losing to Republicans for a traditionally Republican-held seat looks like the effects of a GOP Machine At Work, who am I to judge?