May 30, 2017
Following a four-day layoff and another round of testimony review, jurors in the Brendan Creato murder case told Judge John T. Kelley on Tuesday afternoon they could not reach agreement on a verdict.
The Camden County Superior Court judge told them to return Wednesday morning for further deliberations and try again.
The jury has heard – and reheard – some of the testimony, some as many as four times.
Earlier Tuesday, the jury heard a readback of cellphone data analysis performed by an outside expert, Louis Cinquanto, who was hired by the Camden County Prosecutor's Office.
David "DJ" Creato, 23, is charged with murdering his three-year-old son, Brendan, who was staying with him when he was reported missing and found dead three hours later in Haddon Township, Camden County. He is also charged with child endangerment.
The testimony reviewed his rapid-fire calls, texts and accessing of the social media site known as Snapchat on Oct. 12, 2015.
Testimony showed Creato was on his phone far later than the 10 p.m. he'd told investigators when he was initially interviewed. He repeatedly used his cell until just after 1 a.m. that night.
Creato's use of the cellphone resumed the next morning at 6:02 a.m.
That's when he rapidly called his mother, Lisa Creato, who lives a block away, Haddon Township's 9-1-1 and Samantha Denoto, his former girlfriend and the mother of their son, Brendan.
There was also an early morning attempt by Creato to access his then-girlfriend's Snapchat account. He had her access information.
The prosecution has alleged Creato killed his son, somehow depriving the boy of oxygen, in order to continue a tenuous relationship with his then-girlfriend Julia "Julie" Stensky, a college student from Feasterville, Bucks County.
The pair had met through an online dating site and spent much of the slightly more than three months they were together arguing about Brendan and his mother.
Stensky, who was then 17, continually harped on his son and his former girlfriend of seven years being too large of a part of his life. Creato, who was then 21, had routinely countered that Brendan would always be a part of his life.
But Assistant Prosecutor Christine Shah has pointed to a message Creato sent shortly before the toddler's death that discussed getting a lawyer to discuss custody and review his options.