More Culture:

November 23, 2022

An old-fashioned Thanksgiving side dish to try: How to make potato filling (not stuffing)

The Pennsylvania Dutch pioneered this starchy local staple; create an authentic version with two historical recipes

Food & Drink History
potato filling stuffing thanksgiving Screenshot/Savor it With Stacey; YouTube

Potato filling, shown above, is a Pennsylvania Dutch side dish. Served at Thanksgivings across Berks County, it combines bread stuffing with mashed potatoes.

Thanksgiving dinners across the country tend to feature a few of the same staples: turkey, cranberry sauce, green beans, mashed potatoes and stuffing. But for many Pennsylvanians, there's another star side dish. 

Filling.

A starchy marriage of mashed potatoes and stuffing, filling is a dish with deep roots in Berks County. According to one Pennsylvania Dutch food historian, filling has been around at least since the 1700s, though it didn't take off until the following century. Today, it's as popular as ever. The Pioneer Grange in Topton, which sells its own filling, has customers calling in September to secure the prized side dish for their Thanksgiving meals.

Filling can be used in lieu of stuffing to dress your turkey, but it also stands alone as a side. While there are plenty of modern takes, if you want to create your own authentically Amish (or Mennonite) version, try one of these time-honored recipes. Each is pulled from the archives of the Sunday Patriot-News in Harrisburg. The first was printed in 1955 and comes courtesy of Sally Long, while the second was submitted by a reader, Mrs. C.S. in 1961. 

"It was my great-grandmother's and I am 77 years old, so you know the recipe is a little more than 'sweet 16,'" Mrs. C.S. wrote. "It is very tasty."

Sally Long's Old Fashioned Potato Filling

Ingredients:

8 medium potatoes
2 slices of bread (white preferred)
1 small onion
1/2 cup shortening
6 sprigs parsley
2 eggs
1 tbsp. flour
Milk (amount will vary depending on potatoes)
Salt and pepper

Directions:

Peel and cook potatoes. Add milk and mash as for mashed potatoes. Fry bread and onion in shortening to golden brown. Add to potatoes with parsley, egg and flour. Mix. Add seasoning to taste. If too stiff, add more milk bringing mixture to consistency a little thinner than mashed potatoes. Grease casserole and fill with mixture. Brown in 375° oven for 1/2 to 3/4 hour. Serves four.

Mrs. C.S.'s 'More than Sweet 16' Potato Filling

Ingredients:
1 or 1/2 loaf three-day-old bread2 medium potatoes1 onion cut fine2 eggsParsley, salt and pepper to taste
Directions:
Pinch bread in tiny pieces, add the onion and the eggs. Cut the potatoes as for stewing, cook them 15-20 minutes, and add them to the bread mixture. Moisten the mixture with a little of the potato water to the consistency you prefer. Do not pack the bird too tightly as this filling is very solid. If there is any left over, put it in roaster half-hour before the bird is finished.

Follow Kristin & PhillyVoice on Twitter: @kristin_hunt | @thePhillyVoice
Like us on Facebook: PhillyVoice
Have a news tip? Let us know.

Videos