More Sports:

January 28, 2019

Eagles stay or go: Specialists

Eagles NFL
012819RickLovato Kirby Lee/USA TODAY Sports

Forget Nick Foles and Brandon Graham. What's going to happen with Rick Lovato this offseason?

The Philadelphia Eagles' 2018 season is over, and there will be a lot of interesting decisions made on the players currently on the roster, perhaps more so than in most years. Let's take a position-by-position look at who will likely be back with the team in 2019, and who won't. 


Previous stay or go positional analysis

Quarterback | Running back | Wide receiver | Tight end

Offensive tackle | Interior offensive line | Defensive end | Defensive tackle 

Linebacker | Cornerback | Safety


Today we'll look at the specialists.

Jake Elliott

In his rookie season with the Eagles in 2017, Elliott made 26 of 31 field goals, including a 61-yarder to beat the Giants at the end of regulation in Week 3. It was something of an oddball season as a kicker, as he was money on the long kicks, but was shaky on the short ones. In 2018, Elliott was once again 26 of 31, but his misses were more normal, as they were generally of the long kick variety. A look at his first two seasons in the league:

 Jake Elliott20-29 30-39 40-49 50+ XPM-XPA 
 20175-5 4-7 12-13 5-6 39-42 
 20187-7 10-11 7-8 2-5 33-35 


In both of his seasons in the NFL (and therefore also for his career so far), Elliott is hitting field goals at an 83.9 percent clip. That was good for 21st in the NFL among kickers with at least 15 attempts in 2018 (it was good for 17th in 2017), in a league where kickers are far more precise than they used to be. In other words, he's close to the league average in that department.

Elliott is also roughly at the league average on missed PATs, of which he had two in 2018. There were 64 missed PATs in the NFL this season, which averages out to two per team.

Where Elliott has stood out in his Eagles' career so far, however, is that he has ice water in his veins in clutch situations. In 2017 alone, he did the following:

• He made the aforementioned game-winning 61-yard field goal against the Giants. 

• In the Super Bowl, he hit an underrated 46-yarder with just over a minute to play to extend the Eagles' lead to eight points. Would the Eagles have won the Super Bowl if he doesn't make that kick?

• He was 4/4, hitting from 45, 40, 53, and 47 against the Chargers in a game the Eagles only won by two points.

• He was 2/2, hitting from 50 and 48 in a close game against the Panthers.

• He was 3/3 against the Rams, including a pair of fourth quarter kicks. That game was way closer than the 43-35 score would indicate, as the Eagles got a defensive touchdown with no time left on the clock.

In 2018, Elliott made some big kicks at home against the Texans, Giants, and Cowboys, but none that will be remembered in 10 years. He did have a first-quarter miss against the Panthers that faded to the right in heavy winds in a game where the Eagles could have used those points.

On kickoffs, Elliott can reliably it through the back of the end zone when asked, and is also good at hitting popups that land just shy of the goal line.

Elliott just turned 24 last week. and it's reasonable to expect that he'll only get better. He is actually an exclusive rights free agent this offseason, which means he cannot negotiate with other teams. The Eagles can tender him for peanuts, which they certainly will, and he'll remain with the team.

#JimmyVerdictHe'll run unopposed in training camp like he did in 2018, I'd think.

Your verdict: 


Cameron Johnston

After a brutal start to to the Eagles' offseason camps, Johnston improved dramatically, and hit the longest punt I've ever seen in person during a preseason game against the Steelers:

During the regular season, Johnston was third in the NFL both with a 48.1 punting average, and a 42.7 yard net. Obviously, he had a quiet (quiet is good), but great season.

#JimmyVerdict: He'll run unopposed in training camp, just like Elliott.

Your verdict:


Rick Lovato

Back in the day, I used to watch every long snap of the season. For real, I had serious problems. I don't do that anymore, and as such, I can't speak intelligently on the accuracy or speed of Lovato's snaps, so let's just go the lazy route here and just say that he didn't have any egregious mistakes that I can recall last season. Good? Good.

Lovato is set to become a restricted free agent this offseason. The Eagles will likely tender him at the lowest level, and I imagine he'll return to the team.

Also, it should be noted that Lovato has the cleanest locker on the team. If the cleaning staff has any say, he'll stay. Michael Bennett's is the messiest, by far, in case you're wondering.

#JimmyVerdict: Stay.

Your verdict:


#JimmyVerdict Stay or Go Results

Green = Stay

Red = Go

Orange = Will be back in camp in 2019, but a roster spot is not guaranteed

(Note: Some mobile versions will not display colors.)

 Position
 QBCarson Wentz Nick Foles Nate Sudfeld  
 RB Jay AjayiCorey Clement Darren Sproles Wendell Smallwood 
 RB (cont.)Josh Adams Boston Scott   
 WR Alshon JefferyMike Wallace  Nelson AgholorGolden Tate 
 WR (cont.)Mack Hollins Shelton Gibson Jordan Matthews  
 TE Zach ErtzDallas Goedert Richard Rodgers Josh Perkins 
 OT Jason PetersLane Johnson Halapoulivaati Vaitai Jordan Mailata 
 OGBrandon Brooks Isaac Seumalo Chance Warmack Matt Pryor 
 C Jason KelceStefen Wisniewski   
 DEBrandon Graham Derek Barnett Michael Bennett Chris Long 
 DE (cont.)Josh Sweat Daeshon Hall   
 DTFletcher Cox Timmy Jernigan Haloti Ngata Treyvon Hester 
 DT (cont.)Bruce Hector    
 LBNigel Bradham Jordan Hicks Kamu Grugier-Hill Nate Gerry 
 LB (cont.) LaRoy ReynoldsD.J. Alexander B.J. Bello Paul Worrilow 
 CBJalen Mills Ronald Darby Sidney Jones Rasul Douglas 
 CB (cont.)Avonte Maddox Cre'Von LeBlanc   
 SMalcolm Jenkins Rodney McLeod Corey Graham Tre Sullivan 
 S (cont.) Deiondre HallChris Maragos   
 K/P/LSJake Elliott Cameron Johnston Rick Lovato  
 Head coach    
 Offensive coordinator    
 Defensive coordinator    
 GM    

Follow Jimmy & PhillyVoice on Twitter: @JimmyKempski | @thePhillyVoice

Like us on Facebook: PhillyVoice Sports

Add Jimmy's RSS feed to your feed reader

Videos